Robert the Doll: Key West’s Haunted Mystery

April 16, 2024
Featured image for “Robert the Doll: Key West’s Haunted Mystery”
Podcast Logo
Skeptic Psychic
Robert the Doll: Key West's Haunted Mystery

In this episode, we delve into the fascinating story of Robert the Doll. Robert is a renowned haunted object currently residing at the East Martello Museum in Key West, Florida. Our exploration starts with the life of the doll’s owner, Robert Eugene Otto. We will trace his early years and the strange way he came to possess Robert. Legend has it that the doll was cursed by a servant who practiced black magic. This set the stage for a series of uncanny events that would follow the doll and its owner.

The Legend of Robert the Doll

As we journey through the narrative, we highlight the eerie occurrences that began to surround Robert. Particularly once he was placed in the museum. These phenomena have piqued the curiosity of both skeptics and believers, making Robert a subject of paranormal interest and debate.

Cultural Impact and the Letters Tradition

We also look at the cultural impact of the doll, focusing on the unique tradition whereby visitors to the museum feel compelled to write letters of apology or requests to Robert, hoping to either mend their fortunes or avoid his wrath. This segment not only uncovers the historical context and personal stories associated with Robert but also considers the psychological and social elements that contribute to the ongoing legend of Robert the Doll.

Myth vs. Reality

Join us as we explore the blurred lines between myth and reality, and consider the lasting effects of one of America’s most haunting tales. Whether you’re a firm believer in the paranormal or a staunch skeptic, the story of Robert the Doll offers a compelling glimpse into the ways folklore can weave itself into the fabric of local history, leaving a legacy that continues to fascinate and terrify.

More Info:


Ghosts and Gravestones

Robert the Doll .org

Artisan House in Key West

If you have any questions or comments on this episode or any other. Feel free to contact us.